Shila Devi
In the heart of Amer Fort near Jaipur stands the shrine of Shila Devi, the patron goddess, or Kuldevi, of the Kachwaha Rajputs. The black-stone deity attracts devotees throughout the year and especially during Navratri. Her presence in Rajasthan is linked by a compelling tradition to Bengal, Raja Man Singh I, and an early seventeenth century military campaign against the chieftains of southern Bengal. It is a story of warfare, kingship, devotion, and the transfer of sacred authority, but also one that demands careful handling, because documented history, regional memory, and later legend do not always tell the same story.

Across medieval and early modern South Asia, temples were more than places of worship. They held wealth, expressed dynastic prestige, and embodied a ruler’s divine legitimacy. Conquering armies sometimes looted temples, destroyed royal deities, or carried sacred images home as trophies. At other times, devotees moved images to protect them from approaching armies. These distinct practices form the wider setting for the celebrated claim that Shila Devi was brought from Bengal to Amer.
A Wider History of Sacred Images in Conflict
In the early eleventh century, Rajendra Chola I extended Chola power into eastern India. Historian Richard M. Eaton records that a bronze image of Shiva from the Pala kingdom of Bengal was taken to the Chola capital with images from other conquered territories. This shows that a Bengali religious image could be removed during imperial expansion, although the surviving account does not identify its temple, exact origin, or eventual fate.
Also Read: Bengal Sketches [1],[2],[3],[4],[5],[6],[7],[8],[9],[10],[11],[12],[13],[14],[15],[16],[17],[18]
Around 1204–1205, Muhammad Bakhtiyar Khalji conquered Nadia, an important Sena center. The conquest appears in the Persian chronicle of Minhaj-i-Siraj. Later narratives associate the invasion with attacks on Hindu institutions, but the evidence considered here does not securely establish a named Nadia temple whose principal idol was seized and transported.

In the sixteenth century, Sultan Sulaiman Karrani’s forces campaigned in Odisha and looted the Jagannath Temple at Puri. Accounts disagree about the principal image: some describe destruction or attempted burning, while others say it was carried toward the Ganges. The episode shows the role of sacred images in conquest, but Puri was not in Bengal.
In 1661, Mughal general Mir Jumla invaded Cooch Behar in present-day West Bengal. Historical studies describe attacks on royal temples and the destruction of Bhim Narayan’s state deity. Its association with sovereignty made it politically significant, but destruction is different from removal and installation elsewhere.
Jessore, Pratapaditya, and Jeshoreshwari
In the late sixteenth and early seventeenth centuries, local chieftain Raja Pratapaditya ruled a powerful kingdom in southwestern Bengal, centered on the Jessore–Ishwaripur region in today’s Bangladesh. He belonged to the group of regional chiefs commonly called the Baro-Bhuyans, who resisted Mughal expansion. Mughal forces defeated his kingdom, and the region came under imperial control around 1611–1612.

Ishwaripur is home to the Jeshoreshwari Kali Temple, revered as a Shakti Peetha and traditionally associated with Pratapaditya. Its religious importance is unquestioned, but available evidence does not securely prove that an invading army seized its principal image and carried it to Rajasthan.
A related account concerns Dolgovinda. A modern academic discussion of Bengal’s temple traditions says that Pratapaditya brought this image from Puri to Jessore. During the Mughal invasion, a devotee named Mathuresh Goswami carried it to Shantipur, where it was installed as Radhagovinda. If confirmed from the original references, the story would show devotees rescuing an image during political upheaval, not a conqueror taking it as booty.
The Shila Devi Tradition
Rajasthan’s popular tradition links Shila Devi’s arrival at Amer to Raja Man Singh I, a Kachwaha ruler and trusted general of Emperor Akbar who became Mughal governor of Bengal in 1594. According to these retellings, Man Singh defeated Pratapaditya of Jessore around 1600–1604 and brought a black-stone image of Kali, identified as Jeshoreshwari, to Amer. There, the image became known as Shila Devi, the guardian goddess of the Kachwaha house.
Also Read: Bengal Sketches: [19],[20],[21],[22],[23],[24],[25],[26],[27],[28],[29],[30],[31],[32],[33],[34],[35]
The story presents military victory as a transfer of divine protection from one royal house to another. Its chronology, however, is problematic: Pratapaditya’s final defeat occurred during Mughal operations around 1611–1612, not in a conclusive victory by Man Singh around 1600–1604. The identification of Shila Devi with Jeshoreshwari’s principal image should therefore be treated as a tradition rather than an established fact.
Scholarly research supports Man Singh’s transfer of Shila Devi from Bengal to Amber but offers a different account of the image’s origin. In her 2013 article in Modern Asian Studies, Kumkum Chatterjee identifies the goddess as formerly worshipped by another Baro-Bhuyan, Raja Kedar Roy of Sripur. She interprets its removal as an example of victorious rulers appropriating the sacred images of defeated rivals and notes that Man Singh was not in Bengal when Pratapaditya was defeated.

The frequently cited date of 1604 for the temple’s establishment does not resolve this discrepancy. H. Bhisham Pal’s The Temples of Rajasthan records competing accounts of the acquisition: Man Singh obtained the image after defeating Kedar Raja, or Kedar presented it to him as a marriage gift.
These accounts give the story a historical foundation while leaving the circumstances of the image’s acquisition uncertain. They associate it with Kedar Roy of Sripur, not necessarily Pratapaditya of Jessore, two distinct rulers who should not be confused. The familiar narrative thus blends scholarly evidence, religious tradition, and folklore; it does not prove that Shila Devi came from Jessore.
What Can Be Seen Today?
Shila Devi Temple, Amer: The active shrine stands inside Amer Fort and remains an important center of Kachwaha devotion. Its central image is carved from dark stone, the word shila itself means stone. The deity’s presence, long-standing worship, and association with the royal house are tangible. The sculpture alone, however, cannot prove the exact temple from which it came or the circumstances of its movement.
Shila Devi’s shrine is therefore not diminished by uncertainty. On the contrary, the unresolved questions make it more revealing. The goddess embodies conquest and devotion, royal ambition and popular memory, movement and continuity. Her story reminds us that history is strongest when it honors tradition while refusing to turn possibility into proof
Jeshoreshwari Kali Temple, Ishwaripur: The historic site survives in Satkhira District, Bangladesh, and remains a revered Shakti Peetha. Its continued sacred geography and structures, including the traditional Natmandir assembly space, preserve the memory of Jeshoreshwari worship. They do not by themselves demonstrate that its former principal deity is now in Amer.
Living oral tradition: Folk verses and local narratives in Rajasthan continue to connect Shila Devi with Man Singh’s Bengal campaigns. Oral history is invaluable evidence of how communities remember the past, but it must be read alongside chronicles, inscriptions, temple records, and art-historical analysis.

History, Memory, and the Meaning of the Goddess
The tale of Shila Devi endures because it joins the riverine kingdoms of Bengal with the fortified courts of Rajasthan. It captures a broader truth: sacred images could legitimize kings, mark victory, travel with devotees, and help displaced communities rebuild religious life.
At the same time, responsible storytelling requires clear labels. Rajendra Chola’s removal of a Pala Shiva bronze is a recorded case of an image carried away in conquest. Mir Jumla’s attack in Cooch Behar illustrates destruction of a royal deity. Dolgovinda represents protective relocation by a devotee. The transfer of Jeshoreshwari to Amer belongs to a respected and influential tradition whose precise historical details remain disputed.
Shila Devi’s shrine is therefore not diminished by uncertainty. On the contrary, the unresolved questions make it more revealing. The goddess embodies conquest and devotion, royal ambition and popular memory, movement and continuity. Her story reminds us that history is strongest when it honors tradition while refusing to turn possibility into proof. Further study of Persian chronicles, Bengali regional histories, Kachwaha records, inscriptions, temple archives, and the sculptures themselves may yet clarify how a goddess associated with the east came to occupy the sacred heart of Amer.
Image Courtesy: Wikipedia, Wikimedia Commons, Wikipedia, Facebook, YatraDham.Org, Internet Archieve
Dr. Jamil is a passionate oncology commercial leader whose two-decade journey has been driven by a deep commitment to improving the lives of people with cancer. As Head of the Early Commercial Team at Merck Oncology and an Adjunct Professor at Columbia Business School, he shapes innovative pipelines while mentoring and inspiring future healthcare leaders. Beyond work, he is a soulful armchair historian of Bengal, a devoted Manchester City fan, and someone whose heart is forever tied to the culture, stories, and spirit of Kolkata.